There are Many Ways to Raise a Baby

by Ellen

I saw the most delightful movie last night called, Babies.  It’s a French documentary that follows the first year of life of four babies from different parts of the globe:  Namibia, Japan, Mongolia and the United States.  Child-rearing practices vary immensely from country to country, yet all four children thrive.

Here’s the trailer:

The movie brought back bittersweet memories for me. Being a new parent can be really tough, especially when we push the boundaries of our culture’s norms.

Our Story

When our son was a baby, we co-slept.  I remember going to the Mommies’ Group meetings and being told that I didn’t really need to “worry” about getting him into his crib until he was six months old.  At that point, I’d miss the magic window and it would be much harder to get him to sleep on his own.  I read legions of books on ways to teach babies to “self-soothe” and to be more independent: eat-play-sleep, for example, instead of play-eat-sleep, which seemed to be what Nature dictated every time he’d fall asleep nursing.

We did try to have our son sleep in a crib.  It just didn’t work.  He craved body contact and we weren’t tough enough to “cry it out.”  We tried playing calming music (on a special baby CD player that attaches to the crib rail), sitting with him, singing to him, patting him — everything.  Somehow we knew that it wasn’t going to fly with our baby.  I wasn’t disappointed; I loved sleeping with my warm little bundle.

During the night our baby would wake up whenever he was hungry and I’d roll over to nurse him.  It was wonderful for both of us.  As he got older, people started to ask whether he was in his crib yet or if he was still nursing.  No and yes.  By the time he was two, I started preempting the questions by apologetically murmuring that he was still in our bed.  He was still nursing.  Somehow I was missing the boat on the independence that American children are supposed to learn.

Then I read a book that made me feel better.  Our Babies, Ourselves: How Biology and Culture Shape the Way We Parent, by Meredith Small, is an anthropological look at baby-rearing customs around the world.  So many other cultures co-sleep!  Millions of toddlers are breastfed!  It’s a fascinating book about ethnopediatrics, which points out the dual influences of biology and culture in baby care.  Small says:

Let’s face it — mothers and fathers are molded by millions of years of evolution to do the right thing in raising babies.  We would not have survived this long as a species if this were not so.  And the fact is, babies thrive in a vast array of parenting strategies.  But these strategies are not simply a matter of opinion, tradition, or fact, but a complex mixture of culture and biology, and the way we raise our children does influence our adult behavior.  Ethnopediatrics aims to understand what makes us bring up our kids the way we do; and, with that understanding, to discover what is best for babies.¹

My Gratuitous Advice to New Parents

Do what feels right and try not to worry too much about the right way to take care of your baby.  For every book out there that tells you you’re doing something wrong, there’s another one that will tell you something else.  Either choose your books wisely, or avoid books altogether!

DON’T MISS FUTURE POSTS! Click below to subscribe for free in a reader or via email:


Are you on Facebook?  Please join the BodyEarth Facebook page!


1) Small, Meredith F. Our Babies, Ourselves: How Biology and Culture Shape the Way We Parent.  New York:  Anchor Books, 1998.

Focus Features, Babies, 2010.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Be Sociable, Share!

Comments on this entry are closed.

Jen May 11, 2010 at 9:23 pm

Ohhhh, Ellen, I love this post! Is that your sweet baby boy sleeping in the photo above? I could’ve used that book when my boys were babes…..

Melissa May 11, 2010 at 10:05 pm

I agree, whatever feels right at the time makes sense. I embraced cosleeping and breastfeeding for ~ 2/12 years with my youngest, then when I was ready for the transition, found Elizabeth Pantley’s No Cry Sleep Solution to be helpful.

Looking forward to seeing the movie Babies!

BodyEarth May 12, 2010 at 9:10 am

Thanks so much for your comments, Jen and Melissa! Yeah, that’s my little boy seven years ago. Wow.
It’s great to hear that No Cry Sleep Solution worked for you, Melissa. I remember flipping through it and thinking it was a nice, gentle approach.

Lindsey in AL May 12, 2010 at 5:12 pm

I am getting ready to give birth to my 5th child (about 5 weeks to go) and with each one I have co-slept longer and nursed longer. My 4th was 30 months old when she last nursed (Mama had to quit for hormonal reasons) and she has grand plans to resume when “Born-Baby” arrives (she will be 35 months then). She still creeps into our bed quite frequently, although she also sleeps 10 or more hours at a stretch in her ownty-downty bed. We have been working on that for fears about having a squirmy toddler in bed with two grownups and a newborn. But we also secretly enjoy finding her with her head in my armpit and her feet in Daddy’s face in the morning sometimes.

I have had “fussy” babies and “easy” babies, despite having mothered them mostly the same way. Babies are their own sweet, human selves, right from the start, and other people’s well-intentioned (or not) advice has relatively little effect on the babies or my methods :)

Your basket in the photo reminds me that it is time to dig out my similar one as well as the bedding that goes with it! I love those sweet, sunny sleeping-baby photos in that basket of ours!

BodyEarth May 12, 2010 at 7:40 pm

Hi, Lindsey!
How exciting that “Born-Baby” is almost here! I’d love to hear if your 4th resumes nursing, or decides that she is ready to let go. You seem to have such a sunny, relaxed outlook — lucky babies!

Previous post:

Next post:

Privacy Policy